Skip to content

True Ghost Story: My West Texas Doppelgänger? #evp #paranormal

Not only is the following account a true tale from a recent paranormal investigation, but it is an excerpt from an anthology of true ghost stories called Scared Senseless. I’ve included brief audio files of the EVPs mentioned, so you can hear them for yourself. Enjoy!

Top Notch Ghost Hunters

When Becky Vickers invited me to investigate the Old Park Hotel (OPH) in September 2017, I leapt at the chance. Not only is Becky friendly and fun, but she is an accomplished ghost hunter with a weekly radio show called “Bridging the Paranormal.” She and her team, BECKS Ghost Hunters, have even been featured on the TV show “Ghost Adventures.”

Greg Stephens, from Texas Research and Investigation of the Paranormal (TxRIP), was also in attendance. While Greg didn’t have his team with him, he brought decades of experience along with a heap of equipment. I met Greg while researching Paranormal Texas, my travel guide to haunted places. Since then, I’ve accompanied him on several paranormal investigations. He is always very organized and professional.

Vintage sign at the haunted Old Park Hotel in West Texas (photo by Tui Snider)
Vintage sign at the haunted Old Park Hotel in West Texas (photo by Tui Snider)

Haunted West Texas Hotel

The Old Park Hotel is owned by Dan Lafave and his wife, Connie. Dan has investigated the paranormal for decades and been featured on the news several times regarding famous hauntings in the San Antonio area. Not only did Dan give everyone a through pre-investigation tour of his haunted property, but he stayed during that actual ghost hunt. (I should add that Dan is also an author. I’m currently reading Shadow of the Ghost Hunter, but his book, The Supernatural, Texas & the West, sounds interesting, too!) 

With so many seasoned investigators under one roof, I knew we were in for an exciting night! I say “we” because rounding out this crew was me and Larry.

Archie Debunker…

In addition to being my spouse, Larry is a mad scientist and devout skeptic. Larry is so set in his non-beliefs, in fact, that I nicknamed him “Archie Debunker.” (Of course, if you read my story, “Message from Muriel,” you’ll know that Larry is not able to debunk everything. He certainly tries, though.)

The Old Park Hotel is located in the charming little West Texas town of Ballinger. Like most historic buildings, it’s housed several different businesses over the years, including a secret brothel. Most recently, however, it served as a resale shop crowded with antiques. One theory for why the place is so haunted is that some of these objects had spiritual attachments.

Who knows?

Pre ghost hunt photo with OPH owner, Dan Lafave (photo by Larry Snider)
Pre ghost hunt photo with OPH owner, Dan Lafave (photo by Larry Snider)

Not like a TV show

If you’ve never been on an actual paranormal investigation, but you’ve watched lots of TV shows, then you may not realize how much time it takes to set up for a ghost hunt. It usually takes a couple of hours for a paranormal team to get a haunted location ready for an investigation!

BECKS Ghost Hunters was no different. By the time Larry and I arrived, they had already chosen a room as their command center. This is an important part of a serious paranormal investigation, and at least one person remains in the command center at all times. If they notice unusual activity in one of their monitored locations, they can let other team members know.

The Spirits were ready before we were!

As soon as Larry found a comfortable couch to sit and read his Kindle, I poked my head into the command center. I was about to ask if they needed any help when a man’s voice called out, “Alan! Alan!” from the hotel entryway. This was a loud voice, and everyone downstairs heard it.

Since all the men in our group were accounted for, a couple of us crossed the hall to see this newcomer. I assumed it was a friend of Dan’s.

Who else would walk right into the hotel without even knocking?

Much to everyone’s surprise, the entryway was empty, and the front door was locked. Even so, I stepped outside to look around. The sidewalk and streets were empty. Dan had told us that disembodied voices are a common occurrence at the Old Park Hotel, but we didn’t expect to hear one so early in the evening.

I didn’t even have my digital recorder on, and I’m not sure if any of the other investigators caught this voice. The experience was a good reminder that just because we weren’t ready for the ghost hunt to start,  didn’t mean that the spirits were going to wait for us!

OPH owner, Dan Lafave, is an author, too! (photo by Tui Snider)
OPH owner, Dan Lafave, is an author, too! (photo by Tui Snider)

Doppelgänger caught on tape?

We had a bunch of anomalous experiences that night at the Old Park Hotel, but the one I want to focus on here involves a phenomenon that I have never experienced before, a doppelgänger.

A doppelgänger is when a person seemingly appears in two places at once. My ghostly double made herself known early in the night. Immediately after we heard that disembodied voice shouting “Alan!” I went upstairs to a spot where Dan says investigators often catch EVPs.

While the team finished setting up downstairs, I conducted a brief EVP session. After turning my digital recorder on, I simply asked a question out loud, then mentally counted to ten before asking another question. Rather than talk the whole time, I wanted to leave plenty of blank recording space for spirits (or whatever it is that creates an EVP!) to reply.

At one point I said, “I’m just wondering if I have any company up here with me,” before slowly counting to ten in my head. I was about to ask another question, when Greg hollered up the stairwell.

“Tui!”

“Yeah?”

“Are you singing?”

“No.” I have a rather sing-song voice, so I figured that is what Greg had heard.

“It wasn’t you talking,” he insisted. “This was singing, and she sounded just like you.”

Even so, I didn’t give Greg’s remarks much thought. It wasn’t until the next day, when Becky messaged us and said that she could hear a woman singing, that I began to wonder what was going on.

Inside the Old Park Haunted, a haunted hotel in West Texas (photo by Tui Snider)
Inside the Old Park Haunted, a haunted hotel in West Texas (photo by Tui Snider)

EVP sounds like me!

Here’s where it gets really weird. If you listen to my recording, you’ll hear me say, “I’m just wondering if I have any company up here with me,” followed by several seconds of silence. This silence is only broken when Greg asks if I’m singing.

Unbeknownst to me, however, there was a second recording of this moment in time. Several minutes before my arrival, Becky had left a digital recorder on the table beside me. On her recording, immediately after I say, “I’m just wondering if I have any company up here with me,” you can clearly hear a woman humming a little song. Strangest of all, this woman sounds exactly like me! It is the eeriest thing. If I didn’t know better, I would swear it was a recording of my own voice.

Could this strange EVP be from my doppelgänger?

Inside the Old Park Haunted, a haunted hotel in West Texas (photo by Tui Snider)
Inside the Old Park Haunted, a haunted hotel in West Texas (photo by Tui Snider)

Listen to the doppelgänger EVP here:

You can listen to the EVPs here:

This is MY recording (Greg asks if I’m singing after several seconds of silence.): 

BECKY’s recording (same exact time frame, but instead of silence, there’s an EVP that sounds like me, humming!):

Pretty weird, eh? If Becky hadn’t been taping at the exact same time, we would not have caught this anomaly. I would have assumed that I was humming a little ditty, but simply wasn’t aware of it at the time.

I’m so glad she had put a digital recorder nearby!

My doppelgänger strikes again?

As I sifted through my recordings from our night at the Old Park Hotel, I came across another odd incident. Later that evening, I joined Greg and several others in a room where a mysterious death allegedly occurred.

Out of the blue, Greg goes, “Tui, where you at?”

“Oh, I’m right here,” I said, waving my hand at him in the semi-darkness.

“OK,” he said, pointing to his left. “But it looks like you’re over here.”

“I’m bilocating right now!” I joked, but Greg was puzzled. He went on to explain that he had just seen a slightly shorter version of me walk by on his left. “She looked exactly like you, same hat, same dress, same everything.”

Was this another encounter with my doppelgänger? Why was Greg the only one seeing and hearing this other Tui that night?

Inside the Old Park Haunted, a haunted hotel in West Texas (photo by Tui Snider)
Inside the Old Park Haunted, a haunted hotel in West Texas (photo by Tui Snider)

What are your thoughts on doppelgängers?

When I mentioned this to Archie Debunker, he didn’t roll his eyes or attempt to discredit the experience. Instead, Larry merely said, “Perhaps it was your counterpart visiting us from her existence in the multiverse.”

Since whatever it was looked and sounded like me, I feel comfortable calling it a doppelgänger. But what causes a doppelgänger? I can only guess.

Could it truly be, as Larry suggested, a version of me from a parallel reality? Or is one of the spirits of OPH a really good mimic? What do you think? Have you ever encountered a doppelgänger?

Must return to the OPH!

All I can say is that our night at at the Old Park Hotel was full of surprises. I can hardly wait to return! When I do, do you have any suggestions?

Want to read more?

You’ve just read one of my true ghost stories from the recently released anthology   Scared Senseless by Teal L. Gray. The book includes stories from several other authors, including Mark Elliott Fults, Claudia Hall Christian, Linda Rhinehart Neas, and Cyn Shrader Hill

More Haunted Road Trip goodies?

If you enjoy reading about and even traveling to haunted places, check out my new Facebook page: Haunted Road Trips. Each day, I share interesting tidbits about haunted places all over the world. Join us!

Hey, you! Want to keep up with me?

No matter where you live in the galaxy, Tui's books can take you on a FUN adventure!
No matter where you live in the galaxy, Tui Snider’s books & presentations take you on a FUN adventure!

PRIVATE NEWSLETTER: If you’d like to keep up with me, you might like my newsletter, which comes out twice a month. Use the form below to sign up if you’d like to know:

  • What I’m up to
  • Where I’m speaking next
  • When my next book comes out
  • What’s going on behind the scenes
  • Any other fun news!

As a thank you for signing up to my newsletter, you’ll receive a historic cemetery symbols guide I created called “A Quick Guide to The Many Meanings of Hands.”






Sign up for my newsletter below:

We respect your email privacy

Tui Snider
Follow me:

Tui Snider

Tui Snider is an author, speaker, and photographer who specializes in quirky, haunted, and downright bizarre destinations. As she puts it, “I used to write fiction – but then, I moved to Texas!” Snider's writing and photography have been featured in a variety of publications, including Coast to Coast AM, FOX Travel News, LifeHack, Langdon Review, the City of Plano, Wild Woman Waking, Shades of Angels and more. Snider’s award-winning books include Paranormal Texas, The Lynching of the Santa Claus Bank Robber, and Unexpected Texas. Snider has several more books in progress, including a Field Guide to Cemetery Symbols and a book about the Great Texas Airship Mystery of 1897. Tui has worn a lot of hats in her life – literally – and is especially fond of berets. She enjoys connecting with writers and readers all over the globe through social media, her newsletter and her website: TuiSnider.com.
Tui Snider
Follow me:
Published inBlog PostsHaunted TravelTravel Photo Essays

4 Comments

  1. That is so cool! Thank you for posting the EVP sessions to hear them both–it couldn’t have worked out better to have overlapping recordings of the same time period. It really did sound like you singing!

    • Glad you could hear it! It really threw me for a loop. I’d never give doppelgangers much thought before. I need to record a song based on that melody, don’t you think?

  2. You are so brave for doing ghost hunts. I can only watch on TV during the day. I’d freak out too easily if I tried a real one.

    • I think you might surprise yourself, Patty! I was really nervous before my first ghost hunt, but once I was there, my curiosity took over. :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *